“Victory for the People:” Nestlé Bottled Water Privatization Claim Denied by Michigan’s Second Highest Court

 

 

nestle protest michigan

The general public has largely rallied against Nestlé’s plan to increase water siphoning in Michigan. Photo via UPI.com

 

 

The Switzerland-based Nestlé Global corporation is the largest packaged foods entity in the world, but the company has drawn the ire of environmental and water rights activists in recent years because of its controversial water privatization practices.

In the year 2000 at the second World Water Forum, Nestlé along with a few other corporations persuaded the council to change access to drinking water from a “human right” to a “human need.”

This allowed Nestlé more leeway in acquiring clean drinking water supplies in local municipalities, analysts say, granting them a framework to pump large amounts of it from aquifers and clean water sites across the world for minuscule rates before selling it back to locals and other customers worldwide in plastic bottles.

One of the company’s most high profile controversies has been unfolding in northern Michigan recently, where Nestlé previously sought to carry out what was called “the most extensive water withdrawal in history.”

The company was given $13 million tax breaks to pump water essentially for free, and Nestlé had planned to increase water withdrawals by up to 60 percent, siphoning water at a rate of up to 400 gallons per minute.

But the Nestlé  plans hit a major snag earlier this month after the company lost a key court decision that could put the clamps on its ambitious plans in north Michigan.

 

 

Nestlé Claim on “Essential” Bottled Water Rejected by Michigan Court

Nestlé had argued that its bottled water business operations constitute an “essential public service,” during the trial, but Michigan’s second highest court denied their assertion on the grounds that the local community has other sources of drinking water, a report from MLive.com said.

The ruling came down on Tuesday, December 3, during which a three-judge panel reversed a lower court decision that had ordered Osceola Township to approve Nestlé’s plan to build infrastructure needed to market groundwater drawn from a wellhead near Evart, Michigan.

The decision will make it exceedingly difficult for Nestlé to carry out its aforementioned plan to increase water withdrawals from the area.

“(Nestlé) contends that the draw down will be modest, local, and not affect other wells’ ability to produce water,” the judges wrote in their 13-page opinion.

“Nevertheless, extracting the water and sending it to other places where it cannot return to the water table, and, critically, doing so faster than the aquifer can replenish, is an ‘irretrievable’ depletion unless the pumping is reduced or halted.”

Local activists were especially taken aback by Nestlé’s characterization of its bottled water business as “essential” during the case, and said it sets a bad precedent.

“If a private company like Nestlé is allowed to characterize their services as “essential” just because it happens to be water they’re putting in a bottle, it could lead to the proliferation of water privatization,” said Liz Kirkwood, director of the Traverse City environmental group FLOW.

 

 

 

 

According to Kirkwood, the decision could have far-reaching ramifications beyond the Nestlé case in Michigan. It could also impact a forthcoming decision by a major Michigan environmental department.

While Nestlé has explored plans to reach its 400 gallons-per-minute target, legal challenges and a pending decision from the  Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy have halted them thus far.

Nestlé said that its draw down will be “modest, local, and not affect other wells’ ability to produce water,” the judges wrote.

But they ultimately ruled that the company’s plans could cause critical damage to the local aquifer.

“Nevertheless, extracting the water and sending it to other places where it cannot return to the water table, and, critically, doing so faster than the aquifer can replenish, is an ‘irretrievable’ depletion unless the pumping is reduced or halted,” they wrote.

Nestlé also tried to argue that it supplies bottled water to communities in emergency situations in order to constitute its operations as “essential,” but the judges denied the merits of this assertion as well.

“It is equally clear that, no matter how commendable it might be, doing so is only an incidental portion of plaintiff’s business,” they said according to MLive.com.

For more information on the decision, read the full article by clicking here.

You can also learn more about how the ongoing water pumping has affected wildlife and water levels in the area by watching a video below from the Michigan Citizens for Water Conservation group:

RELATED READING: Why Nestlé Pays Next to Nothing for Michigan Groundwater (Mlive.com)

“The Most Extensive Withdrawal in History:” Nestlé, Michigan Govt. Ignore Widespread Petitions, Decide to Ramp Up Production Anyway

 

A Message From the Founder

Do you want to heal your chronic digestive and autoimmune issues naturally, but don't know where to begin aside from removing GMOs from your diet and buying organic?

If so, you may want to check out the THRIVE Lifestyle Academy, an AltHealthWORKS approved diet, exercise, mindset, and lifestyle program that takes the guesswork out of getting, and mostly importantly, staying, healthy for life.

derek henry kids healing the body

Created by Derek Henry, who overcame 13 different chronic disease conditions thanks in large part to over 3,500 hours of research (watch a short video on his story here), this program is suitable for anyone who wants to transform their digestive health while living a fast-paced modern lifestyle. Like myself, healing his digestive issues (gas, bloating, Crohn's like symptoms) was the gateway to a healthy life for Derek.

Become a member and you'll get a 60-day nutrition jump-start, easy access to the THRIVE Online Health Desk for expert one-on-one support (optional), and a simple eight-part plan ideal for people who enjoy being taught what to do, not told what to do.

Click the button below to take advantage of a special discount for AltHealthWORKS readers, as well as a free 21-day trial to help start your journey.

You can also read real life testimonials from people who overcame their debilitating chronic health conditions here.

Comments

comments

Categories: Uncategorized.
About Nick Meyer

Nick Meyer is a longtime journalist who's been published in the Detroit Free Press, Dallas Morning News and several other outlets. He founded AltHealthWORKS in 2012 to showcase extraordinary stories of healing and the power of organic living, stories the mainstream media always seemed to miss. You can sign up for updates (and receive his free 'Healing Secrets of the Amazon' eBook) by clicking here. You can also check out Nick's Amazon best-seller 'Dirt Cheap Organic' by clicking here, as well as its sequel Dirt Cheap Weight Loss