Your Website Looks Outdated. Is It Time for a Redesign?

By AltHealth Works · · 16 min read

Quick answer

A website redesign replaces your outdated site with one that loads faster, works on phones, and matches your business today. Plan for 2–12 weeks and up to $48,000 for professional work, or about $18–$49 per month if you do it yourself on Wix or Squarespace. The biggest risk is losing your Google rankings. The SEO checklist in this guide shows you how to prevent that.

You built your website a few years ago. It did the job. Now the design feels stale, the pages take forever to load on a phone, and you’re wondering if it costs you calls.

A website redesign can fix that. It can also wreck the Google rankings you’ve spent months building if you skip a few steps. This guide walks through the steps, the costs, the timeline, and how to keep your Google traffic while you switch.

How Do You Know When Your Website Needs a Redesign?

Look at four things. Does your site take more than three seconds to load on a phone? Does it look broken or cramped on mobile? Was it built more than four or five years ago on a platform you can’t easily update? Can you add a new page or change a photo without calling a developer? If two or more of those are problems, it’s probably time.

Google uses the mobile version of your site for indexing and ranking. If your mobile pages are poor, Google judges your site by those pages. Google calls responsive design “the easiest design pattern to implement and maintain,” and it’s the standard expectation for any site built or rebuilt today.

Google’s Core Web Vitals measure three things: how fast the main content loads (LCP, target under 2.5 seconds), how quickly the page responds when someone taps a button (INP, target under 200 milliseconds), and how much the layout jumps around while loading (CLS, target under 0.1). These aren’t the biggest ranking factor. Google says it will still show the most relevant page even if its page experience is weak.

Accessibility is another reason for a website redesign that people overlook. The current standard is WCAG 2.2, published in October 2023 and updated in December 2024. The U.S. Department of Justice has consistently said the ADA applies to business websites, and it references WCAG as a helpful technical standard. If your site was built before WCAG 2.2, it probably has gaps. A redesign is a good time to close them.

If your site runs on a builder that hasn’t been updated in years, or on a version of WordPress so old that plugins don’t support it anymore, you’re carrying both a security risk and a user experience problem. Maybe you offer new services now. Maybe you’ve moved locations. If the site still lists a service you dropped last year, visitors will call asking for it.

Honestly, don’t jump to a full redesign until you’ve checked whether smaller fixes could solve the problem. A speed optimization, a mobile layout tweak, and updated content might be all you need. Running a quick website audit first can save you thousands of dollars and weeks of work.

What’s the Difference Between a Refresh and a Full Redesign?

A refresh updates the visual layer: new colors, fonts, photos, maybe some layout tweaks. The underlying structure, URLs, and platform stay the same. A full redesign rebuilds everything from the ground up, often on a different platform, with new navigation, new page structure, and sometimes new URLs.

A refresh carries almost no SEO risk, because your URLs don’t change. Google keeps crawling the same pages. The only difference is that the pages look different when visitors arrive. A full redesign, on the other hand, can shuffle URLs, delete pages, and change the site’s architecture in ways that confuse search engines if you don’t plan carefully.

RefreshFull Redesign
What changesColors, fonts, images, minor layoutLayout, platform, navigation, URLs, content
Typical timeline1–3 weeks4–16 weeks
Typical cost (rough estimate)$500–$3,000$3,000–$48,000
SEO riskLowMedium to high (if not planned)
When you need itBrand update, visual modernizationPlatform won’t work, major UX problems, structural changes

In our view, a small business website redesign with fewer than 15 pages rarely needs a full rebuild. Usually it’s the template that looks old. The page structure is often fine. Save the full rebuild for when the platform itself won’t let you do what you need. You can’t add pages without calling a developer. The hosting is unbearably slow. The site was hand-coded and nobody can maintain it anymore. Those are rebuild situations.

What Does the Website Redesign Process Look Like?

Four phases: audit the current site, plan the new one, design and build it, then test and go live. Each phase has specific steps you can check off.

Phase 1: Audit. Open Screaming Frog (free for up to 500 URLs) or a similar crawler and save every URL on your current site. Then open Google Search Console. Go to Performance, click the Pages tab, sort by Clicks, and hit Export. Those are the pages you absolutely can’t afford to lose during the redesign. Note your current Core Web Vitals scores so you have a baseline to compare against later. If you haven’t done one recently, our one-hour website audit checklist covers titles, speed, mobile, and broken links.

Phase 2: Plan. Define what the redesign should accomplish. Map out the new URL structure. If any URLs are changing, make the redirect plan in this phase. Choose your platform if you’re switching. If you’re working with a designer or agency, write a brief: what pages you need, what each page should do, what you like and don’t like about the current site, and two or three competitor sites you think look good. That brief saves everyone time and prevents the back-and-forth that doubles timelines.

Some teams create a full website redesign project plan template with columns for each task, who’s responsible, the deadline, and whether it’s done. For a 10-page site, that might be overkill. A shared spreadsheet does the job. Give it four columns: task, owner, due date and status. The formal version starts making sense once you pass 20 pages or involve more than two people.

Phase 3: Design and build. Create mockups or pick a template. Build on a staging site that search engines can’t see: password-protect it (the safest option; a robots.txt Disallow rule stops crawling, but the URLs can still show up in Google if something links to them). Test on both mobile and desktop. Run Core Web Vitals tests on the staging version. Check accessibility.

Phase 4: Test and launch. Check every page on a phone. Test all forms, buttons, and links. Verify every redirect. Have someone who wasn’t involved in the build look at it with fresh eyes. Push the site live during a low-traffic window, submit your sitemap, and start monitoring.

Do the Search Console export before anything else. It takes about 20 minutes. You’ll compare against it at 7, 14 and 30 days.

How Long Does It Take to Redesign a Website?

A simple small business site with under 10 pages on a template platform takes 2 to 4 weeks. A mid-size site with custom design and content migration takes 6 to 12 weeks. Anything with e-commerce, integrations, or hundreds of pages can run 3 to 6 months.

Site typePagesWebsite redesign timelineWhat’s included
Simple refresh5–102–4 weeksNew template, migrate content, basic SEO check
Mid-size custom10–506–12 weeksCustom design, content rewrite, URL mapping, redirects
Complex build50+3–6 monthsCustom development, data migration, integrations, phased launch

These are our rough estimates for a project where the owner has the content ready. How long a website redesign takes in practice depends on content readiness and feedback rounds.

Content is what usually delays a redesign. Expect the copy and its approvals to take longer than the design. If you have all your text ready before the design phase starts, the build goes much faster.

Other time-eaters: custom features like booking systems or payment processing, platform migrations where data has to move from one CMS to another, and three rounds of feedback where each person asks for different changes. We’re not sure the smaller estimates on the internet are realistic for most people. Budget for the longer end of each range.

How Much Does It Cost to Redesign a Website in 2026?

For a typical small business with 5 to 15 pages: doing it yourself on a template platform costs about $18 to $49 per month on an annual plan, most web design projects reviewed on Clutch come in under $10,000, and agencies range from $6,000 to $48,000 depending on complexity.

ApproachCostBest forSource
DIY (Wix)$17.77–$39.77/month (annual plans; US prices, vary by country)Simple sites, tight budgetWix pricing page
DIY (Squarespace)$19–$49/month (annual plans)Design-focused sitesSquarespace pricing page
Web design firmMost projects under $10,000; US firms ~$100–$149/hrCustom design, 5–50 pagesClutch pricing survey
Small agency$6,000–$12,000Custom features, 20–50 pagesWebFX
Large agency / complexUp to $48,000E-commerce, integrations, 50+ pagesWebFX

WebFX puts the full range at $1,000 to $48,000 for a small business website when you include design, development, domain, and hosting. That article was published in 2024, so the numbers may have shifted slightly. Clutch identifies complexity, page count, custom development, and hourly rates as the main cost drivers, and their pricing survey shows most web design projects reviewed on the platform cost less than $10,000. US firms on Clutch charge about $100 to $149 per hour. Keep in mind that both sources sell design services, so their numbers lean toward the professional end of the spectrum.

Photos, copywriting and moving old content are often left out of the first quote. Professional photography, copywriting for 10 pages, and content migration all add hours and money. If your old site has 50 pages but your new one only needs 15, someone still has to review every page and decide what stays. For more context on the full picture, our guide to website costs in 2026 breaks it down across all three paths: DIY, site builder, and done-for-you.

In our view, a standard 5-to-10-page brochure site on a template platform, plus a few days of a designer’s time, shouldn’t cost more than $5,000. E-commerce or a custom booking system will push it higher. If someone quotes you $15,000 for a 10-page brochure site, get two more quotes before you sign anything.

How Do You Redesign a Website Without Losing SEO?

Does a website redesign affect SEO? It can, in either direction. The two biggest causes of post-redesign traffic drops are changed URLs without proper 301 redirects and deleted pages that were actually driving search traffic. Both are preventable if you plan for them before launch day.

Google’s own documentation says 301 redirects do not cause a loss in PageRank. If you redirect your old URLs to their new locations with permanent 301 redirects, the SEO value carries over. Google says to keep those redirects active “for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year.” From users’ perspective, keeping them indefinitely is better.

Google also says that permanent redirects signal to Google that the new URL should be treated as the canonical version. Use 301 (or 308) redirects for pages that have moved permanently. Temporary 302 redirects won’t send that same signal. Ranking fluctuations during a site move are normal. Google’s site-move guide says visibility “may fluctuate temporarily” and that “a site’s rankings will settle down over time.”

In one case Ahrefs documented, a site that deleted about 15 percent of its pages lost almost half its organic traffic. Growth in referring domains afterward didn’t help it recover. Siteimprove lists deleting high-performing content and not setting up redirects among the most common website redesign SEO mistakes. It puts “not establishing benchmarks” as its first item. That’s the Search Console export from Phase 1.

Another common trap: redirecting all your old pages to the homepage. Google’s site-move guide says not to “redirect many old URLs to one irrelevant single URL destination, such as the home page” because it “might be treated as a soft 404 error.” The exception: if you’ve genuinely merged content from several pages into one new page, that redirect is fine.

If your URLs don’t change, your SEO risk is very low. A visual refresh with the same URL structure carries minimal risk. A full redesign that properly redirects every old URL and keeps all important content can actually improve rankings, since the new site may load faster and work better on mobile. Skipped redirects are where traffic gets lost.

The checklist in the next section covers the steps that cause most of the damage. Expect some ups and downs for a few weeks anyway; Google says that’s normal.

What Should Be on Your Website Redesign SEO Checklist?

Break it into three phases: before you start, during the build, and after launch. The “before” phase matters most because that’s where you document what you have and make a plan to keep it.

PhaseStep
Before
(2–4 weeks out)
Crawl your current site with Screaming Frog (free for 500 URLs) and save every URL, page title, and meta description
Check Google Search Console: Performance → Pages → sort by Clicks → Export
Note which pages have the most backlinks (Ahrefs or Search Console’s Links report)
Map every old URL to its new URL (or confirm it stays the same) in a redirect map spreadsheet
Write 301 redirect rules for every URL that changes (see platform-specific steps below)
Record your current Core Web Vitals scores as a baseline
Save your current robots.txt and sitemap.xml files
During
the build
Password-protect staging
Set a self-referencing canonical URL on every new page
Test all 301 redirects before launch
Run mobile and desktop speed tests on the staging site
Check every page on a real phone, not just a browser simulator
Verify all forms, buttons, and links work
Update all internal links to point to new URLs directly (avoid redirect chains)
After
launch
Submit new sitemap in Google Search Console (Sitemaps report)
Submit sitemap in Bing Webmaster Tools: sign in, go to the Sitemaps section for your verified site, and submit your sitemap URL. Bing tries to fetch it right away and usually rereads it at least once a day
Remove any staging-only noindex tags or robots.txt blocks
Check for 404 errors daily for two weeks
Compare indexed page count at 30, 60, and 90 days to your pre-launch crawl

Tape this list next to your screen and tick each line on launch day.

How Do You Set Up 301 Redirects on Wix, Squarespace, WordPress, or Shopify?

Every major website platform has a built-in way to create 301 redirects. The steps take about five minutes per redirect, or you can import a whole list from a spreadsheet.

Wix: Open your site dashboard, go to SEO & GEO, scroll to Tools and Settings, and click URL Redirect Manager. Click New Redirect, type the old path in one field and the new path in the other, and save. Wix supports up to 5,000 redirects per site. For bulk changes, import up to 500 redirects at a time from a CSV file. Note: redirects only work once you’ve connected a custom domain.

Squarespace: Open the Developer tools panel (in Settings on most sites) and click URL Mappings. Each line is a rule in this format: /old-path -> /new-path 301. Add one line per redirect and save. Squarespace processes them top to bottom, so put more specific paths first.

Shopify: In your Admin panel, go to Content > Menus, then click View URL Redirects. Click Create URL Redirect, fill in the old and new paths, and save. For bulk imports, upload a CSV. If you change a product’s URL, create a redirect for the old one.

WordPress: Install the free Redirection plugin (2+ million active installs). Go to Tools → Redirection, click Add New, and enter the source URL and target URL. If you don’t want a plugin, many hosts also have a redirect tool in their control panel. Check your host’s help pages.

Before launch, build a redirect map spreadsheet. Here’s what it looks like:

Old URLNew URLStatusTested
/about-us/about301✓
/services/web-design/services301✓
/blog/old-post-title/blog/updated-post-title301✓
/removed-page(deleted, no redirect needed)410✓

Test every row after launch. Open the old URL in a browser and confirm it lands on the right page. If one is wrong, fix it the same day.

What Should You Watch for in the First 30 Days After Launch?

Watch Search Console closely for two to four weeks after launch. Rankings often dip and then settle.

Open the Page Indexing report in Google Search Console daily for the first two weeks. You’ll see pages grouped by status. The ones to watch:

  • “Discovered – currently not indexed” means Google knows the page exists but hasn’t crawled it yet. Normal for a few days. If it stays there past two weeks, the page may have thin content or a crawl issue.
  • “Crawled – currently not indexed” means Google looked at the page and decided not to index it. Check whether the content is unique enough and the canonical tag is correct.
  • “Page with redirect” means Google found a redirect. Verify it goes where you expect and isn’t chained through two or three hops.
  • “Not found (404)” means a URL that used to exist is now gone. Add a redirect if that page had traffic or backlinks.

Compare your traffic at 7, 14, and 30 days against the pre-launch numbers you saved during your audit. A small dip in the first week is normal. If traffic hasn’t started recovering by week three, check these things first: missing redirects (the most common cause), pages with accidental noindex tags, a sitemap that wasn’t submitted, or an indexed page count that’s lower than your pre-launch crawl.

Check again at 60 and 90 days. Some ranking changes take months to fully settle. By 90 days, traffic should be back to where it was or higher. If it isn’t, something got missed. Our guide on why a website doesn’t show up on Google walks through the full troubleshooting process.

Should You Redesign Your Website Yourself or Hire Someone?

If your site runs on Wix, Squarespace, or WordPress, has fewer than about 15 pages, and doesn’t need custom features, you can probably handle a visual redesign yourself. The template platforms make the design part manageable. Where people get stuck is the technical side: redirects, page speed optimization, and mobile testing.

When DIY works:

  • You’re staying on the same template-based platform
  • Under 15 pages
  • No URL changes needed
  • No complex features (e-commerce, booking, member areas)
  • You’re comfortable spending a weekend learning your platform’s tools

When you should hire someone:

  • Changing platforms (WordPress to Squarespace, for example)
  • URLs need to change and you rely on search traffic
  • E-commerce or booking features are part of the plan
  • More than 30 pages with content that needs migrating
  • Organic search is a meaningful source of leads or revenue

Your options for website redesign services range from a freelancer (typically charging by the hour, often less expensive than a firm) to a small agency ($6,000 and up, best for complex builds with ongoing support). Our comparison of website builders can help if you’re also choosing a platform, and our guide to done-for-you services covers what each option actually includes.

If you hire someone, get the redirect map into the contract. Spell out who builds it, who tests it after launch, and who monitors 404s for the first month. Ask for it in writing before you sign.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should I redesign my website?

There’s no fixed schedule. Some sites look fine after five years; others feel dated after two. Check your page speed, mobile experience, and Core Web Vitals scores once a year. If those numbers are healthy and the design still fits your brand, don’t redesign just because a web designer told you it’s time. A visual refresh every two to three years is more common than a full rebuild.

Should I change my domain name during a redesign?

Only if you have a strong business reason, like a full rebrand. Changing your domain during a redesign adds an entire layer of SEO complexity. You’ll need to file a Change of Address in Google Search Console, set up redirects from every old URL to every new URL on the new domain, and wait weeks for Google to process the move. Keep the same domain if you can.

Will my website go offline during a redesign?

It shouldn’t. Build the new version on a staging server, test everything there, then switch over. If you’re staying on the same host, the cutover can take just a few minutes. If you’re changing hosts, you’ll need to update DNS records, and that can take anywhere from a few hours to 48 hours to propagate. During that window some visitors see the old site and some see the new one, so don’t take the old site down until the DNS change is complete.

How much does it cost to redesign a website?

WebFX estimates $1,000 to $48,000 for a small business website, depending on complexity. DIY platforms like Wix and Squarespace cost about $18 to $49 per month on annual plans. When you get quotes, ask what’s included for content migration, redirect setup, and post-launch monitoring. Those three items are where surprise costs show up.

What’s the biggest mistake people make during a website redesign?

Deleting pages without checking whether they bring in traffic or have backlinks from other sites. In one case Ahrefs documented, a site that deleted about 15 percent of its pages lost almost half its organic traffic. Before you remove any page, open Search Console’s Links report and see which pages have external links pointing to them. Redirect those pages to the closest new page.

Can I redesign one section at a time instead of the whole site?

It depends on the size. Google’s site-move guide says large sites can move one section at a time, but for small and medium sites it recommends moving everything at once so Google can process the change faster. If your site has fewer than about 15 pages, doing it all at once is usually simpler. Keep internal links working between sections and update your sitemap each time you publish a batch of changes.

Sources

  1. Understanding page experience in Google Search results · Google Search Central
  2. Understanding Core Web Vitals and Google search results · Google Search Central
  3. Redirects and Google Search · Google Search Central
  4. How to move a site with URL changes · Google Search Central
  5. Mobile site and mobile-first indexing best practices · Google Search Central
  6. Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) overview · W3C
  7. Guidance on web accessibility and the ADA · U.S. Department of Justice
  8. How to avoid ruining SEO during a website redesign · Ahrefs
  9. Common SEO errors during a website redesign · Siteimprove
  10. How to create a budget for a website redesign · Clutch
  11. How much does it cost to build a website for a small business? · WebFX
  12. Keeping Content Discoverable with Sitemaps in AI Powered Search · Bing Webmaster Blog
  13. Build and submit a sitemap · Google Search Central
  14. Introduction to robots.txt · Google Search Central
  15. Screaming Frog SEO Spider · Screaming Frog
  16. Setting up a 301 redirect for a page on your site · Wix Help Center
  17. URL mappings · Squarespace Help
  18. URL redirects · Shopify Help Center
  19. Redirection plugin · WordPress.org
  20. Importing or exporting URL redirects with a CSV file · Wix Help Center
  21. Web design company pricing guide · Clutch
  22. Wix pricing plans · Wix
  23. Squarespace pricing · Squarespace

Want it done for you? Get a free home page preview →